I would agree. I think the queue theming on Hagrid’s is great. The ride itself is fantastic, but it’s not nearly as immersive as ROTR. It might be my favorite coaster … but it might still be EE. Not sure.
I guess GotG doesn’t count since it’s not in Orlando. I might put that at the top of my list if it were. ToT is great, but not the same. FoP is amazing!
I came off of Hagrid’s the first time thinking … That was fun! I’d like to ride it again.
I came off of FoP feeling completely exhilarated!
I came off of ROTR with a little tear in my eye because it was that awesome.
For sheer enjoyment, FoP or GotG might win out, but for immersive story-telling, it’s ROTR all the way. All that to say … what a surprise that I completely agree with Jeff!