Why did Homecomin’ only received 2.5 stars for Overall Rating, when the Quality, Value, Service, and Friendliness are all 3 stars or higher, and the At A Glance description says “One of the best restaurants in Walt Disney World”?
On the website or in the UG?
1 Like
I just looked, it’s on the website. They’re right, it doesn’t make sense with the other ratings. Chef Art Smith’s Homecomin’ · Disney Springs · Disney World (touringplans.com)
Yeah… it’s “ranked #12 out of 97 Table Service Options at WDW”.
2.5 stars doesn’t seem right to be almost in the top 10 of all TS eateries!
1 Like
You can be popular and well liked without being gourmet. Think of the following Chick-fil-A has. No one would call gourmet, but they back up traffic on the daily.
1 Like
I get that! However, I’d like to know the number of “Stars” of the top 10 rated above it and the next couple rated lower. To not even be 3 stars / “OK” for a #12 out of 97 seems off… 
2 Likes
@Len - Two concerns about the star ratings.
Why does the online description only give it 2.5 overall, when the others are 3’s and 4? What brought the overall down so much lower? Or is that an error?
The Homecoming stars ratings on the web don’t agree with those in the 2024 book. Sure, my book is almost a year old, so something maybe changed ratings.
Overall - 2.5 web, 4 book
Quality - 3 web, 4 book
Value - 3 web, 3.5 book
Service - 4 web, 4 book
Friendliness - 5 web, 4 book
5 Likes
Oh, let me look at that. We might have missed an update. They should match and be higher than we’re showing. Thank you!
5 Likes