Gideon's Peanut Butter Cold Brew

My wife and I want to try the PB cold brew so badly we have semi-seriously considered driving 13.5 hrs each way just to go to Gideons. Has anyone found a good copycat recipe we can try until our next trip?

I’m assuming just adding Torani PB syrup to coffee won’t get us there.

1 Like

I have no idea, but the thought of it horrifies me!

Sorry, that was very negative. Let’s try again. Hope you find a copycat recipe for it.

Wow. I do think the PB cold brew from Gideons is good (and much better than the cookies), but I do hope you’re not semi-serious about driving for it. I’ve never had the Torani PB syrup, but I can’t imagine it would be the same.
Sorry. Not helpful I know.

I’ve seen this recipe on several websites, so I’m guessing it’s pretty close. I haven’t tried it - let us know how it goes!

1 Like

Thanks so much! We are going to try this one tomorrow.

1 Like

So we tried it this morning and it tasted great! I haven’t had Gideon’s so I don’t have anything to compare it to, but two thumbs up.


I tried this one yesterday. I used a French press to froth the milk and it didn’t work for me. However, even unfrothed, I enjoyed the taste, but I’m a big peanut butter fan.