I know it has a ride vehicle based on the tech at FJ. However, I was under the impression there might be "interactions” as with the First Order officers.
I’m glad to know the queue lives up to the hype. I, too, adore the FJ queue. It could be an attraction in itself! (I used to do Ops for the first HP walk thru attraction at WB MovieWorld.) The FJ queue is as good as that entire attraction. It was a fun walk thru thing to do at that park! (Later it became “The Matrix” walk thru)
I like both, but only with HP do I own merch and stuff. So, I guess I lean more towards HP as well…
RotR is the ONLY attraction any where in which I finally feel like I’m in the story. No other ride does this for me. Most rides are, typically, an abridged retelling of the story in some way.
As you’ve mentioned I’ve been fortunate to ride RotR more than 10 times. I did SR queue a lot at DHS, 4 times in one night, and walked on each time. I still like it! I did when the officers did more engagment. I rarley get more than a “go to the blue line” anymore.
I’m gonna say that is a bad tour guide… 
I’m “online friends” with a UOR tour guide. I know they have a lot of flexibility. However, a lot of them just do a “Standard” route and expect the guests to not want more than Express Pass.
A good tour guide would have asked y’all questions about what types of “cool stuff” you were interested in. Maybe gotten you to a backstage area for a show or something.
I know how much these things cost and it’s just not worth the investment for me.
I would prefer to be able to go on my AP multiple days!