Coronavirus Outbreak: Part 2

I just know for months, I have heard people say, “If the vaccine is safe, why do we still have to wear masks?”
I think all the confusion about whether or not the vaccine was good enough has been a stumbling block for a lot of people.

1 Like

I think you are right it would have instilled more confidence in the vaccine if they had adopted that message sooner. And I agree with @Figment20 that they might have delayed while they gathered more evidence to be sure - these are very difficult decisions that affect many people. I do think he had good intentions, if overly cautious. I’m just glad they finally were able to adapt to the new information. Better late than never. :man_shrugging:

5 Likes

Definitely a contract thing. A lot the airline employee groups work under a Collective Bargaining Agreement and changing it to require vaccines would require a Memorandum of Understanding. I’m sure there would be a demand or “ask” from the employee group in exchange for getting vaccinated.

In the short term it’s probably easier to make it a requirement for employment.

1 Like

I was not talking about the GMA piece. I was talking about the video I started to watch with a politician (In March?) going on about how people that had covid were protected. I assumed it was older since I think we were all aware of the different strains at that time.

1 Like

It is my understanding that the original trials for both mRNA vaccines tracked efficacy & safety, not transmission. The data told them they were safe and worked, but didn’t have any content that would allow statements that it would stop recipients from carrying the virus to others.

Over the time since the EUAs were put in place, they did more data collection and that data shows that the vaccine also works against transmission.

I get why they didn’t say it before and why they are saying it now. Think about what would have happened if they publicly stated that the vaccines worked against transmission back in December, and then it ended up that they didn’t!

8 Likes

I have a serious question here. Does Fauci work for the CDC? Does he oversee their work?

1 Like

I think everyone pretty much knew that they have high immunity and can’t be a strong carrier for a number of months after contracting covid or either getting vaccinated. This is why I was stubborn to wear a mask after I had covid in January. I think the 6-8 month time period with a high level of antibodies is correct.

But I do kind of understand the universal masking because you are doing it for the sake of others, so everyone feels comfortable. So yes, appearance played a big part. The other issue is, some people are in the camp that think masks are not real effective, further irritating those that really should not even have to wear them.

So yes, the CDC knew this, Fauci, everyone. I think they held off to make this decision until most adults who wanted to be vaccinated, were. Seemed like an ideal time to break the news. It’s just very difficult to please both sides of the spectrum. It’s a tough job.

9 Likes

Yeah I get that, but back then we were sanitizing everything bc we didn’t know it was airborne then. I chalk it up to more knowledge and more data over time. Plus the fact you can’t tell if someone is vaccinated or not it’s very hard to implement the new guidelines in any enforceable way for the general public unless you do all or nothing you know?

I think the timing of the 12-15 yo eligibility played a part in the timing of the announcement too. Also the % of population vaccinated at least partially. Plus projected forecasting, plus a multitude of reasons we’ll never know.

Now that it is essentially all or none for each individual business I don’t see it being any kind of incentive to get vaccinated. If anything I think it will just make people say ‘see I didn’t need it anyway bc we don’t have to wear masks unless explicitly required by a business’. It’s like the unvaccinated just waited out the guidance. There is no incentive and no penalty so what’s the point?

2 Likes

He works for the NIH
Been there for decades. Is part of the covid response team.

So the criticism is that he publicly supports the CDC guidelines?

The head of the cdc is appointed by the president. When Trump was the president it appeared that most leaders completely ignored the cdc guidance. In fact I think my state’s republican governor might have said out loud that he was using his own medical advisors.

Now, everyone is making rapid changes based on the cdc?

It “seems” to me that the one constant has been Fauci trying to publicly support the cdc guidance, regardless of who was in charge.

Just my personal opinion.

6 Likes

Just answering for my post. I wouldn’t have posted a political post. US Senator Rand Paul was having medical discussion about the efficacy of masks on immune people, whether they gained immunity through the virus or the vaccine. I posted the longer version so context wouldn’t be cut out. I thought it was relevant because Dr Fauci gave two different answers for wearing a mask after immunity. I acknowledged I may have missed the science that changed his reasoning.

Just curious what you think the penalty should be for unvaccinated people?

He gave two different answers, both aligned to what was then the current cdc guidelines. Is that your criticism?

Leadership- you all go into a room, you come out with one message. One Message.

4 Likes

Also during the previous administration the CDC’s credibility was being drawn into question amid changing practices; evidenced in their published guidance. Their guidance that used to be extremely detailed became overly simplified. It was assumed to be due to political pressure and budget cuts which forced downsizing and the possible addition of unqualified staff.

1 Like

What the research told us about the disease changed over that time.

1 Like

Yes it did. As it should have. More data and understanding was gained over time. Sounds like science to me :wink:

4 Likes

you wouldn’t believe the amount of tests they run in the ER (well maybe you would!). I’m going to draw every $1000000 sendout test that only gets run in france, before I look at the cbc result and order a monospot!

1 Like

Aren’t they implying the penalty of being unvaccinated is that they SHOULD wear a mask when others who are vaccinated don’t have to? Like isn’t that the argument now to get vaccinated? I’m just saying it’s a moot point bc you can’t tell either way. So vaccinated or not you have to wear a mask in required locations and if you aren’t vaccinated and aren’t wearing a mask in places it is not required no one would be any wiser.

3 Likes

Ya’ there’s the rub. But unvaxed are only putting other unvaxed at risk right now. Exceptions would be immune compromised who the vaccine isn’t as effective due to their condition and/or treatment. So they would want to continue to :mask: mask. It would be nice if the honor system would work to protect those still needing our care.

2 Likes

Senate Hearing: ‘It’s not theater, it’s variants.’
GMA: ‘Until the recommendation changes I didn’t feel comfortable being seen in a room with people unmasked, I didn’t want to send the wrong message.’

I’m not taking a side, just pointing out what sounds like inconsistencies to me. Both answers may very well be based off of CDC Guidelines. This hearing was the first thing I thought of after hearing the GMA piece so thought I’d share since people were confused.

2 Likes