Back for my 2021 trip I requested room 4337 in the 1960s building. I can’t find the room I actually ended up getting but it was great. It was in the 1950s building Building 2, on the top floor with a great view of the lake. I wasn’t too far from the bowling pin stairs so it was a nice walk around the lake to get to the skyliner.
EDIT: This was NOT close to the food court. Meets all the other criteria though
Call the resort desk about a week before your stay. Make your request. We stay the 60’s building as well because it is close to the Skyway. Never had much luck requesting via Touring plans.
Quiet room is subjective so I think that’s hard for a room assigner to determine. To meet all four of those would be difficult. Non-connecting rooms on any floor tend to be quieter rooms. Buildings 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, and 10 are all close to the food court and all have standard rooms.
I’d put in the notes section of the TP request that you’d like a non-connecting room in one of those buildings and that the non-connecting room is your priority. That gives the room assigner a lot to work with. I think you’d be really limiting yourself with the top floor request or top floor and nonconnecting. But if top floor is what you really want then note that as your main priority.
I’ve had my room request met by only using TP request 8 of the 10 times I’ve asked. The first two times were the very first times I requested and I made no notes about what I wanted or why. I just left the TP text. After that in the notes, I asked for any room in building 4, 5, or 6 to be close to the Skyliner and have had that request met 8 out of 8 times.
I have found that corner rooms facing the lagoon are generally the quietest - avoid facing the pools at all costs!! - and have lovely views. As for distance to the food court, the only time I was really unhappy about the distance was when I was placed in the far end of the 50s (I haven’t stayed in the 90s yet but I imagine it’s the same issue there). Even the rooms close to the Skyliner were only a couple minutes of walking. Pop isn’t huge which is one of the reasons I love it!
Do you care which pool you end up near? We loved the pinball shaped one and only ended uo there by chance. Of course the big one has more stuff. I was there in 2015 so things might have changed though.
I was at Pop last week. I had my room request met via TP request. Asked for building 4, 5, or 6. Got building 6. Was there in March as well. Asked for building 4, 5, or 6. Got building 5. Both times I arrived at Pop around 11:00AM. I got the room ready text within an hour of arriving.