Good discussion! I LOVE making a spreadsheet - my family thinks I’m nuts. I will say, though, that my spreadsheet is all about “flexibility within structure.” I like to have maybe one ADR each day so I have something that I know is happening. It gives me direction and keeps me from doing the “what should I do now” dance. I also like to make sure I don’t miss any opportunities - parades, shows, early entry, parties - because I wasn’t ready for it.
For our upcoming Disneyland trip, for example, I know which park we are going to early on the first two days, I have a Fantasmic! dining package reserved, and we’re having afternoon tea at Steakhouse 55. The third day is totally empty at this point. We’ll ride what we want and get FPs for what sounds fun. I know if I didn’t plan I would have missed out on those extras (like the Paint the Night reception, which is already sold out on our nights because I didn’t jump on it).
We don’t always splurge on the extras, but it sure is nice to know we have a spot to eat and view something before we start.
That’s my two cents!