Dogs don’t slam doors in the middle of the night, or get so drunk that they throw up all over the room. Dogs don’t flood the parks like the notorious Brazilian tour groups apparently do. They don’t hold up iPhones and iPads during HEA, blocking other people’s views, or hoist their children onto their shoulders.
The implication of some of the posts on this thread is that because there are some bad dogs — or, rather, bad owners — all should be banned.
There’s also an unhealthy dose of massive generalisation going on, too. I rather get the impression that YC is strewn with dog poop, deafened by dogs barking, and littered with the wheezing bodies of people keeling over through their allergies.
In the UK I only ever stay at dog-friendly hotels and I only ever stay in at least 4* properties. I’ve never, ever, ever heard a dog bark in the middle of the night in a hotel. I’ve never, ever, ever seen dog poop inside a hotel or near the walkways. I have been woken up by drunk people returning to their rooms late at night, and by earlier risers thoughtlessly slamming doors in the mornings.
Twenty years ago I was having lunch with a friend and she was distraught because her cat had recently died. I didn’t get it. I said, “What’s the problem? Get another cat.” Apparently that didn’t help.
Now that I am a dog owner, I get it. My dog is 100% a member of my family and I’m not leaving him behind. He comes with me. Well, OK, not when I fly to America because of the impracticalities of that. But he stays in my home, looked after by people he knows. But on all other occasions he stays in hotels with me.
If someone can point me towards authenticated accounts of dogs barking in Disney hotels — and not just a quick bark because someone knocked on the door, but sustained barking that causes legitimate irritation in other guests, then I’m interested to read those accounts. But if all anyone can do is dream up hypothetical nightmare scenarios, then I’m not interested.
As for dog poop, let’s see some photos of how the landscaping and pathways are littered with it. And then I’ll show you photos of toilets at WDW where people have peed on the floor, or on the seat, or not flushed, or . . .
Live and let live. Dogs are allowed in some rooms in some hotels. Dog owners pay a huge premium for this.
If I lived in the US, I would for sure take my dog to WDW. I wouldn’t leave him in the room all day, I’d take him to daycare. And I can promise you this — you won’t hear a peep out of him, unless you knock on my door. And I always, always, always clean up after him.
Don’t tell me other people are different. Because humans are every bit as problematic at WDW as dogs (allegedly) are.
And, actually, while I’m on a righteous roll, tell me about these allergies. I get hayfever. I’m not petitioning for trees and lawns and flowerbeds to be banned. I take medication to deal with it.