First DCL cruise! 5-nights Bahamas on the Magic (planning thread - renamed)

We’re now two weeks away from committing to this cruise, and I’m getting so excited!

What’s even BETTER is that I’ve also gotten my mom so excited about the idea of a Disney cruise with family that she has talked her sister into joining us. My kids and I are very close to my auntie and she’ll be turning 80 on the day we board the ship! So I’ve changed our reservation to have two adjoining state rooms (still in oceanview rooms on Deck 2, slightly more forward than midship, near the forward elevators) and can’t wait to make amazing memory across the three generations.

Our window for booking activities opens in just under a month. A few quick questions about this (paging @lolabear_la who I’m certain knows the answer to most if not all of these):

  • We definitely want to meet the princesses in Royal Court, am I correct in understanding that this is the first thing I should try to book the moment the window opens? Can I book for all 5 of us in the same party if we’re staying in separate state rooms?
  • My girls would love to do Bibbidi Bobbidi Boutique (we’ve never done it before!) Am I correct in thinking this should be the second priority for booking? I’d like them to be in there are the same time or immediately after one another, and ideally I’d like to do this on our Rapunzel night or on the formal night - but am not sure how I’ll know which date that is? The only night I definitely don’t want to do it is on Pirate Night cause I have no doubt they’ll want to dress up for that too.
  • The only other thing I’d like to prebook is the Extreme Getaway Package for myself and my daughters on our Castaway Cay Day. My mom and auntie will definitely not ride bikes or snorkel. They may be interested in seeing the stingray experience. Is it possible for people who are not booked in the experience to watch from nearby/take pictures of the three of us with the stingrays? I am thinking they’d probably be happy just seeing us do it for 5 minutes and then returning to their beach chairs rather than hanging around for the talk/wanting to feed the stingrays themselves :joy:
  • For Lookout Cay, I’m planning to just relax on the beach. My mom is still fairly mobile, but my auntie moves with a walker and would definitely need a golf cart for the trip along the pier. Can I somehow book these in advance, or are they just available for folks with mobility issues on the day-of?
  • For our Nassau Day, I was already wavering on whether or not we need to get off the ship (my mom and I have visited Nassau in the past). With my walker-dependent auntie now joining, and the cruise being only 5 days, I’m 99% certain we’ll just stay on the ship that day and hopefully take advantage of low crowds at the pool/water slide and other areas. Am I missing any great excursion or opportunity by not getting off at Nassau? If there’s something really special, I could always go just with my daughters and leave the older generation to enjoy the ship :slight_smile:

Thanks so much in advance for your thoughts and advice!

2 Likes

So happy you’ve got more family coming to enjoy! And happy to answer any and all questions I can!

I think you’re asking about Royal Gathering. If so, that is the princess meet that is no additional cost but does require a reservation. It is a hot ticket to get, but it actually does not open at your loyalty status booking window. Instead it opens for everyone at 30 days out. For first time cruisers, it’s also the time you can do online check-in to upload your ID documentation and select a port arrival time. If you want the princess meet you definitely want to try for that first, then start your check in.

Also, a small note, this meet is done in the atrium instead of the Royal Court. Also, if you don’t get this for your first cruise, you can absolutely still meet princesses around the ship and sometimes in even prettier locations (like Preludes near the Walt Disney Theater or against the murals around the atrium or even on the balcony with the chandelier). The biggest benefit of the Gathering is that you get 3-4 princesses met with a fairly short line to do all of them. But you can still meet them all by paying attention to where and when they will be meeting.

If you mean the princess activity in Royal Court, that will be the Royal Court Tea. It is also a fairly hot ticket item and depending on your sailing might have spots available when the booking window opens. It is a pretty penny at $250/child and $75/adult, so you do want to make sure you are so excited for it and are mega princess fans who love a tea party. We did this for the first time on the Fantasy and my youngest and I were in heaven, DH loved watching us enjoy it and the other kids were grateful for it, but are ok having done it once.

Also, fair warning, the food is only ok. Some of the desserts are great, but not all of them and it’s pretty pricy for what food you get, but if you factor in the entertainment value, it’s pretty fairly priced. The kids price is so much higher because they get a ton of swag/merch and so it’s essentially forcing you to get that by booking (an autograph book & pen, a toy, a plushie, a crown and a cape). And finally, it’s only available to book for those with children ages 3-12 to book and children must be accompanied by at least one adult. If you want this, I would definitely go for this first when your booking window opens.

It is a great experience! We’ve done it mostly at DLR but did do it once on the Wish. I preferred it at the parks, but the ship had Captain Mickey & Minnie outfits that are not available at the parks and my younger kids were over the moon excited to get from the experience. And the attention they got on the ship was profuse, from all crew everywhere the whole time they were decked out.

The hard thing with BBB on the ship, is with a first time booking window, it may be hard to find a time that isn’t a conflict with any of the shows or dinner and isn’t in the middle of one of the private island port days. If you have the first seating dinner is at 5:45-7:15pm (or so) and the show each night will be 8:30-9:30pm (or so). If you have the second seating, shows will be 6-7pm (or so) and dinner 8:15-9:45pm (or so).

Also, the first time you will be able to see what shows/restaurants and dress themes are which night is when you connect to the ship WiFi at port. So for booking you won’t have that yet. But you won’t have to worry about it conflicting with Pirate Night. On Pirate Night, they transform BBB to a pirate makeover space and it will only show as open for Pirate makeovers which will be a separate experience from the BBB makeovers.

You may be able to find out what night is the dress-up night or when the Rapunzel show is one of two ways: 1) call DCL and ask for the tentative planned schedule for dress-up nights and shows for your specific cruise or 2) joining the sailing specific FB group & asking the group if anyone knows. Someone else may have called already or, a concierge guest may share the tentative schedule that is shared with them to guide their requests that they can submit.

When bookings open, it is also fairly easy to find out which night is pirate night by seeing which night has the pirate makeovers too. And I like to do that once the dust settles on my first couple of bookings just to see if the schedule I am going of off is still on track (i.e. pirate night is on the night I had planned for it to be).

We’ve done the Getaway package that has snorkels, bikes and floats but not the one with the String-rays also, so I’m not sure how the setup is there and if it will allow your mom and aunt to observe. I would look for reviews or vlogs on DISboards, Facebook, YouTube or Instagram for those who have done the experience and wrote it up or took video to find out. Knowing how lax the staff is around Castaway, I would say it’s highly likely that if there is a space they can view from the beach, they won’t be prevented from watching for pictures for a bit. But like I said, we’ve not done the Stingray one.

Talk to Guest Services as early in the trip as you can. I’m not sure exactly when they start taking requests but I know starting the night before they announce that if you need a golf cart to speak with Guest Services and that those who waited until day of were often not able to get a time until 10:30am-11:30am so if you wanted to be on the island earlier, I would go no later than the morning before to check if you can request one, just to get as early of a time as possible.

When I first started researching Nassau it seemed like the best things to do were the Atlantis Water park, Blue Lagoon (and now Baha Mar) beach day or walk around enjoying the historic sights near the port. If you are big water park fans, Atlantis does still seem to be a draw, and what I’ve read about Blue Lagoon and Baha Mar as beaches has been mostly all good, but my family is good for one beach day on a 4 night cruise, and 2 on a 5-7 night.

Our first cruise was supposed to be a 3 or 4 night that included Nassau & Castaway Cay on the Dream and my plan for Nassau was to get off the ship and walk to the Fish Fry to try some Bahamian specialty, crack conch and conch fritters. And then if my family wanted, walk around to the fort, Queen’s Staircase and maybe even walk through the Pirate Museum. Since then I’ve also discovered that there is a public library near the port that is in a historic octagon-shaped building and has a small exhibit of Bahamian history on one level (and used to be a jail but has been transformed to be a lot more cozy with book nooks instead of cells). We’ve ported now in Nassau 5 cruises and got off once, tried the conch that I had always envisioned getting (and it was tasty!) but then got right back on the ship because it was just too hot to walk in the heat and my family wanted to go swim in the pool instead. We do generally use it as a day to get in more time on the ship that we already paid to experience. But one day I hope to get more time to walk around and see some of the sights.

As for on the ship, we find it slightly less crowded of a ship, but a lot do still stay on, so it’s not a very quiet ship. The morning hours might be quieter on the ship as most people who leave, leave in the earlier part of the day, but by lunch/afternoon it starts to feel more like a regular sea day as people come back. The very quiet ship days will be for ports where most the ship gets off (Castaway Cay for sure, Lookout Cay too, and most other islands besides Nassau). That said, unless you really want to experience a Bahamian beach (and a 3rd beach day) or if Atlantis appeals to you, I’d recommend staying on the ship.

2 Likes

Also, I forgot to add initially in the BBB section, if you really can’t figure out a time that doesn’t take you away from dinner or a show or time on the beach, then check the app once you’ve connected to the ship wifi at port on embarkation day (or go to BBB that first day) and ask if there are times available. They may hold back times for walk-ups that first day on a first come, first serve basis and you’ll be able to see better availability. You can also ask them about putting the two appointments you need at all the same time. They are able to take multiple kids at a time so it is possible to have them doing their makeovers next to each other at the same time.

Also, joining the FB group might help you find someone who has an appointment that wants to drop it and they can arrange to drop it when you’re available to grab it. Or you’ll see a post that someone’s dropped appointments and can check in the app for it.

2 Likes

Realizing I missed this question. As long as your reservations are linked together (you can do this in the app by adding the other room so you can see it in the app), you should absolutely be able to select everyone. When we went on our first cruise with the extended family, I could see all 4 of our combined staterooms by doing this and could’ve booked things for us all together (if there had been space for anything, we went on a full cruise and were first-timers who totally missed the booking window so it was kind of slim pickings by the time we figured out what was what).

2 Likes

Thanks so much @lolabear_la for the comprehensive advice as usual. SUPER useful!

Yes, this one! I’ll keep that as my first booking priority then as soon as my window opens, though it’s good to know that even if I don’t manage it should not be too difficult to find the same princesses another way.

Will keep this as second priority then, but manage the girls’ expectations, in case we don’t manage to find a spot. Thanks for the tip about calling to check the dining schedule and on the possibility of embarkation day walk-ups! Either way I’ve promised them they can get dressed up and they’re excited about that. BBB would just be the cherry on the cake.

Perfect, will do that on our embarkation day then!

Great, thanks - still leaning firmly towards this option!

2 Likes

I certainly don’t think that you are missing anything by not getting off at Nassau but I think you should probably check the “low crowds” expectation a little. Most people also have the same thought and while it’s slightly less crowds than a sea day it’s not like the true low crowds of a good port day. I also think that what they have done with the port area is quite impressive, so even if it is just for one hour it could be worth hopping off to look at the shops right there at the port. It should be pretty accessible for those with mobility challenges.

3 Likes

I paid off my cruise in full at the 90-day mark, so it feels even more real now! I got the Disney travel insurance (because it was around $100 less than what the Allianz website quoted me).

Two key milestones ahead, and grateful for any advice on my planned strategies/questions from all of you more experienced cruisers:

Booking activities this Sunday 13 April (75 days out as a first-time Disney cruiser):

  1. Top priority will be BBB appointments for my girls, timing flexible. I called DCL to ask about our dining rotation and they recommended booking BBB for our second night, suggesting that Pirate Night was likely to be scheduled on day 3 (I will double check this in the BBB schedule once activities are open). If there’s no appointments left, I’ll try to pick them up after boarding. I’ve told my girls (8 and 10) that they can pick out a dress in advance (sometime more comfortable and perhaps slightly less childish than the poufy princess gowns in the boutique - I found some nice options on onlylittleonce.com via Etsy, but would love suggestions of similar princess-inspired/bounding vendors if anyone has them (the older one is having a hard time choosing something). Any other tips for easy dressing up with kids on cruises, e.g. for pirate night? I really wasn’t planning to go all out, but now that the time is approaching, thinking about costumes seems like such a fun part of the planning escape :slight_smile:
  2. Second priority is the Extreme Getaway Package for Castaway Cay (day 2), no real preference on timing except before lunch, especially if we manage to get BBB for that afternoon. Am hoping this one shouldn’t be too difficult to get.

Check in day: 28 May
My top priority for this day will be to try to snag spots for Royal Gathering. Then I’ll try to check in both staterooms, ideally for an early boarding time but I’ll be happy with whatever we get. We’ll be driving in (my mom lives about 1.5hrs drive from Port Canaveral). I’ve read check in instructions here on the Forum and will have passport scans and portrait photos ready. Does anyone know if I need anything special for non US citizens? My auntie will be traveling on a German passport with an ESTA.

We can’t wait!

2 Likes

Wow, booking activities for DCL is a whole new level of glitchy - a very frustrating experience, but I did ok in the end. I wasn’t going for anything super competitive and mainly wanted to get a feel for the booking system as a practice run for the upcoming check-in/Royal Gathering day, so I decided to log on right at opening time (4am my time, so I had to set an alarm and am sure that I was not at my sharpest!)

My first move was to check BBB availability. I could see that the times for our Day at Sea had already advanced to 6pm, which seemed too late if we wanted to catch a show. There were still some afternoon times available on both our Castaway Cay and our Lighthouse Point days. When I had called DCL to check on our dining schedule, two separate advisers recommended booking BBB on the second night of the trip (Castaway Cay day), which is scheduled to be “formal night”. I managed to book three appointments for that second day, though the appointments start earlier than I wanted (at 3.15pm) and are not really at the same time, just adjacent (the latest starts at 4.45pm).

Then I got stuck for 45 min just trying to refresh on both the website and the app, everything seemed frozen and unavailable. I logged in and out multiple times, and tried an incognito window, but nothing worked. At one point when I logged it in actually looked like I had no cruise reserved.

I kept clicking around and about an hour after I first logged on, I managed to book the Extreme Getaway Package for our Castaway Cay day, at a time I wanted (manta rays at 11am, snorkel/bikes/floats rental whenever you want). I was happy with that.

But then I started wondering if I shouldn’t have booked BBB for Lighthouse Point day, when we are not planning to do any shore excursions (the rays, the bikes and snorkeling near the sunken Disney statues in Castaway Cay looked much cooler than anything available at Lighthouse Point). So I tried checking availability for that day, but just got totally stuck for several hours.

It’s so annoying that you can’t see availability for BBB on another day if you’ve already booked something - you have to blindly cancel what you have just to see availability and then hope you can find a good alternative.

The other problem was that the system seemed to be down again, and I couldn’t even cancel the reservations I had anymore - it keps saying to try again at another time. I went back to sleep and tried several times throughout the day on the app (I was moving around all day and couldn’t get back on the laptop until this evening).

I managed to get back in through the website just now (the app is still spinning aimlessly) and play around a bit with cancellations and exploring other availability. Unfortunately the BBB times for Lighthouse Point are now also out past 5pm, meaning it would run into the times we might want to watch shows, so I decided to stick with my BBB times on Castaway Cay day.

I may decide to drop either the Getway Package or BBB that day (if I can find three slots together on another day/at a good time), so that we don’t feel rushed doing both on the same day. BBB is a must-do for my girls at some point during the trip (whereas the Getaway Package is nice to have but not a must - we would likely also be happy just renting bikes and snorkels on the spot). If anyone has thoughts on whether BBB starting at 3.15pm on Castaway Cay day is cutting it to close, let me know!

But wow, the booking system is really worse than I thought.

In much better and more important news: the reason that I was looking for three BBB appointments and not two (for my two daughters) is that my sister spontaneously decided yesterday that she’ll join us for this trip with her DS11 and DD9! We’ve been to WDW with them once (their only visit and they have also never cruised before) and they loved it, so they will lose their minds with excitement when they find out (my sister hasn’t told them yet).

My mom is in heaven that the number of grandkids on the trip have just doubled, my kids are super excited to spend time with their cousins, and I am just LOVING this ever-growing multi-generational family trip that I know will create incredibly memories!!

Easily makes the DCL glitches pale into insignificance by comparison :slight_smile: In the meantime I’ll keep expectations low for check-in day/the hunt for Royal Gathering next month…

4 Likes

How wonderful you sister and her family are joining you!

Everything about Disney pre-boarding is ridiculous. I’ve done multiple other cruise lines and nothing comes close.

2 Likes

I’m sorry for the rough initiation! It sounds like you got the full order of issues that most everyone gets (including the page where it looks like you have no cruise booked), unfortunately. :roll_eyes:

Disney technology and the way the website cannot maintain connection when it overloads is abysmal. But like you said, the glitches are very insignificant compared to the sailing overall and the memories to be made! And so happy to hear that your sister and the cousins are now coming along! It really is an awesome family vacation.

That’s pretty decent for a first time! My first time the only appointments were 6pm on all the days except Castaway Cay and on that day appointments were only available midday! So that’s actually pretty good!

As it’s the must-do for your girls, I would definitely keep them! You can keep looking and if you find what you want, take the risk to drop what you have and hurry and grab the one you want (I would recommend using two devices to have one to cancel and one to be ready for the new time if you do want to do it, and it helps if it’s an off-peak time that people aren’t usually online).

And then if embarkation day comes and you’re still looking, as soon as you get to the port, connect to the ship wifi and check right away on the app for any times when you want them. And as a last effort, as soon as you board, go right up to BBB to ask them to help you adjust them for when you want them. If BBB doesn’t open that early, check if Guest Services can help or if you need to wait until BBB opens (I believe they open right at 12-12:30pm with the rest of the ship, but I don’t know if that’s always the case on every ship, especially the Magic & Wonder where they are kind of tucked away in a very far corner of the ship).

Castaway is a lot of fun and has a lot of activities to do, so freeing up time on that day is always a good thing. And it’s always been a breeze to walk-up and do the snorkel and bikes rentals day of, especially with the Magic having less passengers. The island is a LOT less crowded when you sail on the smaller class (Magic/Wonder). But it is possible to hit those later afternoon times for BBB. Most people leave the island between 2-3:30pm and so you’ll be in good company. And if the appointments are still staggered that means you just need to budget enough time for whoever’s up first to be fully ready (with sand-free clean hair) at 3:15 so if they are able to shower quickly you could all head back at 2:15-2:30pm. If you end up with appointments at the same time, I would probably budget more like 90 minutes for getting to the ship, getting everyone cleaned up, and then to BBB together. So it does just depend on how much time you want at Castaway. And if you are able on vacation with a big group to be dressed and breakfast eaten and ready to get off the second they start letting everyone off (usually around 8:30am).

1 Like

This is just crazy to me. The Magic has 875 state rooms. I just looked it up and there is just one other ship with a sailing leaving the same day (the Dream, 1250 state rooms). If we assume that even just one-third of those 2125 state rooms are not first-timers but one a higher tier (and can therefore start booking earlier), there should be an absolute maximum of around 1400 people trying to book on the day that activities open. That includes people who like me who have one person booking for several state rooms, and I think it’s safe to assume that at least some people are not crazy Liners who stay up until midnight (or set alarms for 4am) to book their cruise activities. Maybe I’m missing something in my thinking, but I’m just baffled that Disney seems to be unable to build a website that doesn’t crash when around 1000 people are trying to book things at the same time?! They should be used to much higher volumes from the parks, no?

Oooh, this is clever will keep it in mind in case I do want to change. But I think I’ll just hang on to what I have for now, and then maybe just try to get them a little closer together on embarkation day. Glad to hear you don’t think it’s way too rushed for Castaway though. I think we can definitely be quick getting back & ready. I’m less optimistic about getting off the ships at 8.30am (and definitely not with the whole group - I am thinking maybe we try to go earliesh with the kids who will be awake anyway, and let my mom and auntie sleep in/have leisurely breakfast and then just join us for a couple of hours whenever they’re ready. They won’t do any of the Getaway activities with us, but will be happy to lie in beach chairs and float around in the water a bit.

Speaking of, how long is the walk from the ship to the beaches on Castaway Cay - and is there any assistance for those with limited mobility? I’m thinking my auntie will probably be fine with her walker on this day (I’ll definitely book assistance for Lighthouse Point), but if it’s scorching day she might be more comfortable getting a lift in a golf cart at least in one direction?

1 Like

According to Apple Maps it’s 900 ft (and a 4 min walk) from where you get off the ship to the first tram stop. Then you can tram to the beaches to reduce walking.

I know they have golf carts (for concierge and wedding parties), but not sure of the ability to use them to get to the tram stop.

I can’t figure it out either. But seriously they should be able to handle the load. Even if all of their fleet has a booking date open for all first-timers. They are not that gigantic of a cruise line that it’s impossible to figure out that website traffic.

All I know is that I set alarms for for 20 and 10 min before booking opens, every time we book, (opens at 10pm for us), and DH turns off any devices that are streaming, we turn wifi off our work computers (and if it’s the summer/weekend and so any of the kids are maybe awake, has them turn off any streaming games/movies & take a screen break while I book) because every little bit of speed I can get helps me get in with less loading issues and possibly be done quickly (sometimes I’ve been done in 5 minutes, other times it’s been hours of checking & re-checking if I can now get in to either the app or website and in those cases, no amount of us not using any other internet bandwidth helps so after about 20 min, we usually let the family go back to normal wifi usage, it’s just to give me a jump on getting the website loaded right as it opens up).