Extra magic hours ? Split stay

We are coming to WDW over Thanksgiving. Our 1st night will be spent on property at a value resort. The last 4 nights will be at a non-Disney off site hotel. We already got magic bands and made fast pass reservations. 3 of 4 of us have annual passes and we purchased 3 day park hopper tickets for one of us. I know that all of this is linked to the magic bands. I know we can access extra magic hours that first night if our visit since we are staying onsite. My question is whether we can use our magic bands for extra magic hours the other nights/days of our visit, Any ideas?

Check in day and check out day only. When they scan your band the other days, they will see you are not staying onsite and you won’t be eligible.